“Twin Peaks” premieres on ABC
Imagine pitching a show where the town sheriff communes with spirits through cherry pie, a one-armed man receives messages from a dancing dwarf, and a Log Lady carries cryptic pronouncements carved into wood.
This wasn’t your average whodunit; it was a metaphysical puzzle wrapped in a murder mystery, sprinkled with quirky humor and unsettling chills.
Yet, against all odds, ABC, a network known for its fluffy sitcoms and family dramas, took a colossal gamble, greenlighting “Twin Peaks” and betting on the vision of two audacious creators – the enigmatic filmmaker David Lynch and his writing partner, Mark Frost.
This is the story of that improbable gamble, of a show that defied every convention, captivated audiences, and forever changed the landscape of television.
The 1980s marked a significant shift in the television landscape. The dominance of network television was challenged by the rise of pay cable, basic cable, VCRs, and independent stations. This led to a significant drop in network viewership. In 1979, 91 percent of TV viewers during prime-time were tuned to a network. By 1989, the number had dropped to 67 percent. This shift in viewership dynamics forced networks to rethink their programming strategies and consider more innovative and adventurous content, paving the way for a show as unconventional as “Twin Peaks.”
The networks were in a precarious position. They were losing viewers to cable TV, which was perceived to offer better entertainment programs, greater program variety, and better-quality programs overall. The networks’ response to these changes was largely unsuccessful, with a lineup of new series that failed to yield a single big hit. This failure underscored the need for innovation and risk-taking in programming.
The first piece of the puzzle is the creative team behind “Twin Peaks.” David Lynch, known for his surreal and often disturbing films like “Eraserhead” and “Blue Velvet,” was not an obvious choice for network television. However, his partnership with Mark Frost, a television veteran who had worked on shows like “Hill Street Blues,” created a unique balance between Lynch’s avant-garde sensibilities and Frost’s understanding of television storytelling.
The initial pitch for “Twin Peaks” was a gamble. Lynch and Frost presented the idea of a murder mystery that would not necessarily be solved, focusing more on the town’s quirky inhabitants and the strange occurrences within. ABC, looking to differentiate itself and take risks in a competitive market, decided to greenlight a pilot. The two-hour pilot episode, directed by Lynch, was a cinematic tour de force that set the tone for the series. It was weird, beautiful, horrifying, and unlike anything else on television.
ABC’s decision to air “Twin Peaks” was more than just an attempt to replace old content with something new and shocking. It represented a significant shift in network television programming, signaling a willingness to venture into the unknown. This gamble was a response to the changing television landscape and the need to attract a disaffected audience.
Despite its initial high ratings and cultural buzz, “Twin Peaks” struggled to maintain its audience. Its narrative complexity and refusal to provide easy answers frustrated some viewers. However, the show’s influence was undeniable. It pushed the boundaries of what was possible on television, paving the way for the golden age of TV drama we’re experiencing today.